you are here: iVillage Love Love message boards Hot Topic: Games People Play  / Games People Play  / 

Hot Topic: Games People Play

3080 messages posted to this board
find messages about   
welcome!
 
last visit to this board
9/5/2007


add to friends
ignore posts
discussion title:
 

Why is he denying?

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  299.1
replies:
  5
from:
date:
  9/2/2007 5:53 pm

Hi,

After my boyfriend started changing his routine about a month ago, I started to snoop a little and found he'd been hiding things from me.

I discovered frequent phone calls day and night for weeks (that were on our phone bill) between him and a former female co-worker. When I confessed that I had snooped he was obviously upset and a big fight ensued, and in the last few weeks I have found myself on the defensive for "snooping" and not trusting him. He told me the ex-co-worker has been depressed about work and her relationship issues and needed someone to talk to. He also insisted that she is not his type at all and can't understand what there is for me to be insecure about.

It may not have grown to such proportions if he had just admitted to their "friendship" from the beginning and been open about phone conversations and meetings (which I also discovered). But the fact that he hid it and then denies their frequency when the evidence is on the bill, makes me feel something is very wrong. The more I question him, the more we fight. I offer to show him the bill, but he doesn't want to see it. He'll get angry and try to change the subject to my snooping and how unhealthy it is.

I've told him the fact that he is denying these calls (and I believe occassional lunch or dinner dates) is what makes me trust him even less, but he he tells me all I need to know is that he loves me, would never cheat or be unfaithful to me and I should trust him. He claims I'm ruining our relationship by my lack of trust and I say he is ruining our relationship with these denials (and lies)?

The truth is I don't mind if he has female friends as long as he respects the boundaries, like not calling 10 times day and night. I know I have had male friends who had girlfriends while I was single or in a relationship, with whom I'd chat or call late at night once in a while. But this is too much.

I have tried to see his side. We have lived together for 3 years, and I hate to just give up relationships, but I can't make sense of all this , even with all his reassurances, and it's eating me up.

Could this relationship be really innocent like he says? I know that he does like it when people need advise and I have seen him spend days on end with guy friends talking/chatting about certain issues. But why would he hide or deny this particular relationship? Now that I know about it, why can't it be out in the open? Just last night I felt he had called her and asked to see his recent calls on his phone. He handed it over to me and to my surprise, he had cleared all recent calls, but of course he denied that too. By denying the extent of calls, is he trying to not give in to me as punishment for my snooping?

I haven't been able to talk to friends, because I don't think they can be objective in this.

Thanks

last visit to this board
9/3/2007


add to friends
ignore posts
discussion title:
 

Why is he denying?

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  299.2 in response to 299.1
replies:
  5
from:
to:
date:
  9/3/2007 4:53 pm

Let him go. I was in this situation before; I say trust your gut feeling. If you think he's doing wrong, he most likely is. And, if tries to flip it on you about snooping, he's guilty. If there was nothing there suspicious, you wouldn't have to snoop! You'll be better off without him.
last visit to this board
9/5/2007


add to friends
ignore posts
discussion title:
 

Why is he denying?

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  299.3 in response to 299.2
replies:
  5
from:
to:
date:
  9/3/2007 6:27 pm

Thanks for the response.

Last night the bf came home and told me he had something very important to tell me. He said that the woman friend that he'd been talking to in secret had recently been sexual assaulted by another of his ex-co-workers and he'd been trying to keep this a secret for her sake. He said she's completely devastated, but is afraid of going to the police for fear of what people may think.

He said he's only telling me this now because he realized that it's hurting our relationship. He also said he feels really bad that he's breaking a promise to her by telling me, but he feels he has no choice. I'm still not sure if I can trust him, inspite of this shocking revelation.

It's gotten to the point where I doubt everything he says. Does this sound like b.s.?

Thanks

last visit to this board
9/5/2007


add to friends
ignore posts
discussion title:
 

Why is he denying?

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  299.4 in response to 299.3
replies:
  5
from:
to:
date:
  9/5/2007 11:13 am

Sounds fishy still. She is confiding this crime to him rather than reporting it to the police? Whether or not the assault occurred, your boyfriend isn't a rape crisis counselor. She's being a damsel in distress, he's being knight in shining armor. Noble. But inappropriate. I wouldn't like it either.

In our society, someone who has been assaulted sexually can obtain really great support by contacting rape crisis centers. If she really wants help, that is.

last visit to this board
9/12/2007


add to friends
ignore posts
discussion title:
 

Why is he denying?

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  299.5 in response to 299.3
replies:
  5
from:
to:
date:
  9/5/2007 4:00 pm


If you aren't ready to end the relationship, then you have to set some boundaries, because frankly, what he's telling you is very suspicious. The whole tactic of turning it around on you, making it *your* fault that you feel you can't trust him, playing the sympathy card with the sexual abuse thing - this all smacks of emotional abuse and manipulation.
Set some boundaries! Tell him that you are willing to give him the benefit of the doubt provided he stop ALL telephone calls, e-mails and personal contact with this woman. Period. There's no room for discussion here - what he is doing is inappropriate. Even if the woman was assaulted, she needs to be discussing that with law enforcement and a mental health/rape crisis specialist, not your boyfriend.
If you are more important to him than this woman is, he'll break off contact with her. If not, well, you have your answer, don't you?
Change the number of messages
displayed on this page in
Indicate your interest in the discussion
   
Get updates to this discussion
delivered by email