Bereavement & Healing

25181 messages posted to this board
find messages about   
welcome!
 
discussion title:
 

Grief Might Not Be So Bad After All

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  5764.1
from:
  cmamyd  Member Icon
date:
  Nov-4 2:04 pm
replies:
  8

What do we know, or think we know, about the way we respond when a loved one dies?

We pass with the dying through the Kübler-Ross stages — denial, anger and so forth. We realize that people who seem happy or even crack jokes after a terrible loss are faking it and that we will pay a psychological price for not dutifully attending to our own “grief work.” We seek therapy or grief counseling, and if we would rather not, we berate ourselves for living in a harmful state of denial.

Read more: http://newoldage.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/10/22/grief-maybe-not-so-bad-after-all/

re:
 

Grief Might Not Be So Bad After All

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  5764.2 in response to 5764.1
to:
  cmamyd  Member Icon
date:
  Nov-4 6:23 pm
replies:
  8

Two of the comments after the article are worth pointing out:

I thought this one was beautiful:

What would really do some good is for everyone to assist a few people on their steps through death’s door. I’ve been fortunate enough to work in that world, and it’s taught me that death is a miracle at least as great as birth. While I sure miss a lot of now dead people, I also celebrate their lives and their ultimate triumph.

This one corrects the article:

To be fair to Kubler-Ross, she was careful to caution, as I recall, that one does not move “from one distinct predictable phase of grief to the next,” but that each person copes in his or her individual manner. The phases she postulated were guidelines only. In all acute cases one may expect to find her analysis useful.

re:
 

Grief Might Not Be So Bad After All

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  5764.3 in response to 5764.2
from:
  cmamyd  Member Icon
date:
  Nov-5 9:38 am
replies:
  8

Yes, that first thought you quoted really is beautiful, and so true.  As for the second, also true.  I have found when I've had occurance to deal with grief that the phases of grief do not occur in any particular order and are different for each situation.
re:
 

Grief Might Not Be So Bad After All

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  5764.4 in response to 5764.3
from:
to:
  ALL
date:
  Nov-5 2:27 pm
replies:
  8

Hi

I so agree that the stages of grieving have no set order and also that there are different types of grief.  I know this sounds weird but I have found that my grieving has followed different paths for different situations.

I always believe that is was a honor to have those who I have lost as part of my life, no matter for how short a time.  It was a privilege to have been part of their lives and remembering that has given me much comfort.

Promise 

 

re:
 

Grief Might Not Be So Bad After All

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  5764.5 in response to 5764.4
from:
date:
  Nov-15 1:11 am
replies:
  8

Grief is bad, and the stages which Elizabeth Kubler Ross wrote about do not really exist in the same order for everyone. Each death is different, everyone reacts differently to death. You bury your 87 year old grandma, you shed some tears, but you are thankful she had a long life. You cannot expect the same reaction from someone who lost a spouse, a sibling or a child. I think that the loss of a child is the worst possible loss and until it has been personally experienced, it cannot be explained. This November will be 12 years since my seventeen month old daughter died. I miss her as if it were yesterday. Time does not heal all wounds. You learn to live with the loss, you can never accept it. I applaud those who can accept losing a child, I cannot. I was the one who carried her for nine months, I was the one who lost her unexpectedly. I was the one who watched her lying in that tiny pink casket. I was the one who went to pieces emotionally and mentally when they asked me to leave so they could lower her little casket in the hole. I am one who came back to an house where her laughter was suddenly silenced. I am the one who got rid of friends who read Elizabeth Kubler Ross' book and proceeded to determine for me what stage I was at and what stage I was going to next. If I sound a bit angry I am, death is not nice and neither is grief. There is nothing mild about grief either. I applaud those who are able to accept the loss of a child. I buried my father as a young girl, my mother when I was pregnant with my first child. I know about death and grief. There are no stages to grief, you just have to live with that hole in your heart, put on a happy face and keep your tears to yourself. Since no one likes to discuss death because it scares them, people are even more uncomfortable with anyone who displays grief. Death no longer scares me, I have a plot right next to my daughter, living without her is the challenge.
Change the number of messages
displayed on this page in
Indicate your interest in the discussion
   
Get updates to this discussion
delivered by email