I really don't think you can go wrong with any of those. I love them all.
Luke Anthony is my least favorite because I hear Luke a lot more often on kids (on its own or as a nn for Lucas). It also makes me think of the character Luke on General Hospital who's played by Anthony Geary.
I voted for Henry David because it makes me think of Henry David Thoreau and Henry's always been a favorite of mine. Charles and Edward are my second and third choices.