you are here: iVillage Pregnancy & Parenting Pregnancy & Parenting message boards Circumcision Debate  / Resources & Q&A  / 

Circumcision Debate

102482 messages posted to this board • 3 messages posted today
find messages about   
welcome!
 
last visit to this board
Nov-14


messages posted
this board
106

add to friends
ignore posts
discussion title:
 

Hello

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  8135.1
replies:
  10
from:
  harmony08  Member Icon
date:
  3/31/2009 12:13 am

I see many familiar faces on this board - but I should probably introduce myself from a circumcision POV. So here's the story.

The only thing I ever heard growing up about circumcision was from a male friend who had a father who was intact, he said his fathers penis was gross, all the children had circ'd penises, my friend was glad he was circ'd. When I was pg with my first I didn't know boy/girl and was considering the circ issue. My dh at the time was circ'd and happy with his penis. My mom freaked that I was considering this at all and told me my dad was intact and it was gross. Apparently my father had a hygiene issue. I had a girl and was glad not to have to make that decision, because I had heard such negative things about remaining intact but my gut told me it was better.

Fast forward a few years a divorce and and a few more years to my remarriage, and I got pg with boy/girl twins. This time we knew the genders ahead of time. I have three stepsons and all are circ'd, dh is circ'd, I thought I'd let dh decide, and he said circ. I was okay with it, though still had a nagging feeling. My twins came 10.5 weeks early and were in the NICU a long time. When it came close to my son being discharged they asked about circ and I said yes, signed the consent form and everything. That day or the next twin boys in the same room were circ'd. Their mom was not present and one of the boys would not calm down after. I watched the nurse try and try to comfort him, and saw her concern that he would not settle and we all watched the heart monitor racing and beeping. It took a long time for him to be okay.

I told the nurse right then that I wanted to be present for the circ. No way was my son going through that and being left with only a nurse to comfort him, I'm the mom that's my job. She added that to the form. That night I told dh about it and our discussion led to a lengthy internet search and dh saying that he only circ'd his oldest because the doctor said it was necessary, he originally planned to say leave it alone. He agreed to have the others circ'd because he believed the original doctor. I found that the AAP did not recommended it (I was not surprised given what I had researched about circ years before).

I was worried about how my son would feel being intact and so I stayed up late reading a bunch of message boards trying to get the male and female POV (my mother's reaction to my father's intact penis still bothered me). I found lots of pictures of circ/intact and erect/not erect penises. I agonized over trying to predict what my son would want, and not wanting to make a decision he would later be unhappy with. I still wasn't 100% sure but with tenuous confidence and dh's agreement, I went into the NICU in the morning and ripped up the consent form. I breathed a sigh of relief when I did it. My son is the only intact male in a family of 5 men and personally, I think that's going to be just fine.

"If you don’t like something, change it; if you can’t change it, change the way you think about it." - Mary Engelbreit.

Photobucket
last visit to this board
Nov-22


messages posted
this board
596

add to friends
ignore posts
discussion title:
 

Hello

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  8135.2 in response to 8135.1
replies:
  10
from:
to:
  harmony08  Member Icon
date:
  3/31/2009 4:48 am

Hi Harmony! I'm so glad to see you here! *hugs*

Thanks for sharing your story.

Kudos to you for following your heart amongst all that opposition.

Yes, your son will be fine. My son is intact. All my family is intact. Nobody's penis has fallen off! They all still work. They don't smell. Nobody's had to have their foreskin chopped off later and none of them would want to either!

Around 80% of the world's men are intact so he's in good company.

Rose, loved for life by Meghan and mama to Michael Lloyd (24th May 2005) and Ella Morghan (5th Jan 2008). Hoping to conceive Tomas Luca or Carys Bryn by 2010.

Lilypie Baby Ticker

Lilypie Baby Ticker

preview image

Lilypie Baby Ticker

                          Photobucket

                         

                                     

That message deleted

last visit to this board
9:45 am


messages posted
this board
2262

add to friends
ignore posts
discussion title:
 

Hello

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  8135.4 in response to 8135.1
replies:
  10
from:
to:
  harmony08  Member Icon
date:
  3/31/2009 10:14 am

Welcome!

I see you've "met" our resident troll who is currently known as "bicoastaldude".

Have you also visited the Foreskin Support board? The posters there are a wonderful resource for any questions you might have. They're at http://messageboards.ivillage.com/iv-ppwithforesk .

Of course you can ask questions here as well, I like to offer multiple options when possible.

last visit to this board
12:45 am


messages posted
this board
516

add to friends
ignore posts
discussion title:
 

Hello

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  8135.5 in response to 8135.1
replies:
  10
from:
to:
  harmony08  Member Icon
date:
  3/31/2009 9:27 pm

Hi Harmony

My son is the only intact one in the last two generations of immediate family.  My FIL is intact, and so is my grandfather, but other than that, it's unheard of.  My mom is Jewish, so I had the religious guilt, and my SS is circ'ed, so SO didn't understand why I was so adament about leaving Cam intact.  He still questioned it after Cam was born (and home two weeks) but he's finally getting used to it. 

I just don't see his penis as being anyone else's business after he's out of diapers, and until then I'm the one to change him 99% of the time, and he's the only boy I've ever changed. 

Elissa


Powered by CGISpy.com
Thank you Spencer and Susan!
PhotobucketPhotobucket
 
Lilypie Breastfeeding Ticker
Change the number of messages
displayed on this page in
Indicate your interest in the discussion
   
Get updates to this discussion
delivered by email