you are here: iVillage Pregnancy & Parenting Pregnancy & Parenting message boards Homeschooling  / New to Homeschooling  / 

Homeschooling

76545 messages posted to this board
find messages about   
welcome!
 
last visit to this board
Nov-12


add to friends
ignore posts
discussion title:
 

Criticisms

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  10095.1
replies:
  36
date:
  Oct-19 7:46 am

How do you handle criticisms from family???  You know, the ones that say "she won't have any social skills" or "why would you do that for?" etc.

I'm having some of this thrown my way and wondered how you guys handled it.

A part of me wants to say "mind your own business, it's my life and my kid and I think I know best"...... you know what I mean???

I haven't quit PS yet, that will be in about 2 weeks but starting to tell people now.  So here come the Critics out of the woodwork!!!!!!!

 

Frustrating.............

Your New HS Buddy ~ Melisa
http://www.ladyemily.com
last visit to this board
Nov-20


add to friends
ignore posts
discussion title:
 

Criticisms

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  10095.2 in response to 10095.1
replies:
  36
from:
  tmpavlac  Member Icon
date:
  Oct-19 9:21 am

Honestly, I point out all the things that my DD is involved in with other kids (Sunday School, gymnastics class, Homeschool group) on a weekly basis and explain that part of the reason we pulled her out (not the total reason, but it's one of many reasons) was because the school was not providing a social outlet for my child anyway. They came to ME asking ME what I was doing for social outlets outside of school and specifically said that she needed outside social outlets because the school wasn't providing much social time. I was also concerned that the only social time my DD had was during lunch time, which came at the expense of her NOT EATING OR DRINKING anything all day long. They didn't go out on the playground or have any unstructured free time during the day. So, what difference does it make if my child is educated at home or not? She's not losing out on those social interactions.

Besides, why does a child need to be interacting socially ONLY with his/her age-mates? My DD does a fantastic job interacting with the kids of various ages at our homeschool group. In fact, she has been interacting quite well with a 10 year old and my DD is 6. And why is it inappropriate to learn some of her social skills from other adults as well as her age-mates or kids of varying ages?

You could very well ask what the questioner is defining "socialization" as being. And if "socialization" simply means interacting with people other than your immediate family, list off the various activities that your child will be involved in with other kids/people. If "socialization" means interacting with kids of the same age-group, ask why kids need to interact only with their age-group, when we as adults can interact with people who are years older or years younger than we are and that's perfectly ok. We as adults don't go up to someone, ask how old they are, and then refuse to talk to or become friends with that person simply because they aren't the same age. That would be crazy. Why can't our kids be involved with other kids?

One thing that might be really beneficial to you is to join up with a homeschool group in your area. I know that my DD likes going to our homeschool group because then she's interacting with other kids who are being educated in the same way she is. It's a great way for her to realize that she's not the only homeschooled kid around and that it's not "weird" or "abnormal".

Stay in contact with what school friends your child has made and try to set up playdates when you can. I think it's important for kids to keep those positive connections and don't feel like you need to make excuses for your decisions. The public school isn't working out for you or your child. I try not to slam the public school system to other people who are using it, simply because they may have no other choice...or maybe it's working for them. But, I just say that it wasn't working for us and we decided to go another route.

I hope homeschooling is a very positive experience for you all!

Photobucket Visit my Blog with lots of gluten-free recipes: http://glutenfreebeginnings.blogspot.com
last visit to this board
Nov-20


messages posted
this board
3329

add to friends
ignore posts
discussion title:
 

Criticisms

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  10095.3 in response to 10095.1
replies:
  36
from:
  hbkk20
date:
  Oct-19 9:30 am

I love critics, they make me want to work even smarter here at education. I generally point out how messed up society is, how messed up kids are, you messed up they are....then they go away. How is it all those "kids"  in jails went to school until they dropped out or were locked up....didn't school teach them social skills and values? No....they had bad parents....how did schools teach those kids to be such bad parents? Oh, but there are some smart, well adjusted kids at school, like thiers....really, how materialistic are they? How much flack to you get back from them in attitude? Is that fabulous socialization? How do they treat other kids at school who are not in their little clique? How are those test scores? Any outside tutoring happening after school....oh that is home schooling, that is what we do. Why should you be allowed to help your child with thier homework if they learned everything at school? Why are their million dollar companies that tutor children who are FAILING at schools? Is it the kids, the families, ohh...it IS not your fault they are over crowded at school due to the bad economy....yet even with this neglect at school, you still think my homeschooling is a NEGATIVE? Our class size is better than tutoring centers! I try my best to seak out decent social environments for my children, my kids are eat their veggies because they get fresh ones at home aka our school....I could go on and on....but why. They are not listening just whining because they can't do this and they know many schools have many problems!

Oh....my school has problems? yes true a few, BUT....well less than yours! Thank You we will do this a while longer, yes...it is legal to be a parent and be in charge of your children, it is even legal for you who go to regular schools...so try it, when your kid IS at home...like over the summer maybe.

Heather    

last visit to this board
Nov-17


messages posted
this board
4456

add to friends
ignore posts
discussion title:
 

Criticisms

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  10095.4 in response to 10095.1
replies:
  36
from:
date:
  Oct-19 10:50 am

Most people are just curious and come across as criticizing. It's funny some of the things they bring up- like we never thought about our kids social lives, or algebra. One of my favorite replies is "I think I have mastered _____ grade. I think I can pass that info on to my kids. " That is especially good for low grades. For algebra, again... I passed it with an "A" so I think I can teach it to my kid. I did have to learn a bit for the trig (precalculus now) but I never took that. *lol* Guess what? I CAN learn! Even better, I can learn WITH my kids!

I've learned more about history homeschooling my youngest than I ever learned in school, and I remember it now. Why? I found something that is presented in a way that isn't like reading a stodgy, musty old textbook.

Ignore those who are confrontational. Change the subject. Turn the tables and point out all the ills of the alternative (public school).

last visit to this board
6:41 am


add to friends
ignore posts
discussion title:
 

Criticisms

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  10095.5 in response to 10095.1
replies:
  36
from:
date:
  Oct-19 11:16 am

I acknowledged that the potential for isolation was there if I didn't make an effort to get my children involved in activities.  Then, I listed the activities they were already involved in, and told them about our local homeschool group and all the fieldtrips/clubs the kids could be a part of.  Chances are,  time will be the best indicator for the doubtful.  My mother-in-law was skeptical, but is now a supporter (two years later), all because she sees that my kids are still the "normal" kids they were before.  :o)

Melinda
 

                                   Photobucket
Change the number of messages
displayed on this page in
Indicate your interest in the discussion
   
Get updates to this discussion
delivered by email