Hi Sandra, I'll up my 2cents in. : )
I think that what you said about regretting now having a third is telling to how strongly you feel. And it's great that you have your Dh's support.
"i feel like financially, we are finally on our feet w/ just 2 kids.. 1 more year of 2 dy care payments until older DS goes to K-garten" - Well, I don't have any of my kids in daycare, so that might be a deal breaker for me. Could you work some of your hours at night or exchange childcare with another mom to help with the expense? The one thing I always say about finances though...there is never really a good time financially to have kids. There are always expenses and reasons not to. So why listen to that? : )
"will I have enough time for all 3? What if they all have sports events occuring on the same days? will I be spread really thin?" - You will have enough time for all 3. It'll be tough and a royal pain getting them all to their events and you will be spread thin a times. And it will all be worth it. : )
HTH a little! Good luck deciding! It's a tough place to be! I have one older brother and always wanted at least another sibling. My Dh had an older sister and always wanted another sibling too (he did get a younger sister, but she was adopted at 6 months when he was 16, so they aren't very close). My children LOVE each other and while they fight constantly, they really do love each other. Then again, there are a lot of things that we give up for having a large family (like no vacations to Disneyland). So like you said, it's ultimately up to you and your Dh. Again, best of luck to you!
~