you are here: iVillage Love Love message boards Breaking Up Is Hard to Do  / Healing or Reconciling  / 

Breaking Up Is Hard to Do

120153 messages posted to this board • 6 messages posted today
find messages about   
welcome!
 
last visit to this board
Nov-22


add to friends
ignore posts
discussion title:
 

After 5 years, can you be friends?

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  27555.1
replies:
  3
from:
date:
  Nov-3 6:41 pm

I was dating my boyfriend for almost 5 years. We met in high school and we shared all the first together. By no means was our relationship perfect. We broke up twice, once for a week and once for about 3 months where I saw other people but he didn't. He didn't treat me the way I wanted to be treated but I always loved him and he always loved me. By the end, I wasn't happy and it was a mutual break up. However, he was always my whole life when we were together. We spent every day together, and always spent all day texting each other. It's been a week and a bit since the break up and it's been really hard. I know that this is what I wanted and it was for the best but that doesn't make it hurt any less. After a breakup, you always remember all the good memories and forget the reasons why you should be happy that it's over. I have the big fantasy of one day meeting the man that I've always read about in romance novels and I know that he could never give me that love.

The hard part is my connection to his family. Me and his oldest sister were always very close. We still chat everyday, and I think we are friends not only because I dated her brother. However, after 5 years together, I love his family as must as I still love him. I know that my love for him will never go away because it was my first love. But his family wants me to keep in contact with them and to occasionally go to dinners at their house. While I would one day love for that to be possible, I don't know if it ever will. I want to believe that we can be friends, but is that a delusion? Can lovers ever really be friends? If they can't, then what, do I just have to cut him out of my life completely and never talk to him again? I don't think that I'll ever be okay with him with another girl, because I feel like he never treated me right and I'd be bitter if he treated her right. But could we stay in contact, talking over msn once in a while, and never talk about our new relationships?

last visit to this board
Nov-3


add to friends
ignore posts
discussion title:
 

After 5 years, can you be friends?

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  27555.2 in response to 27555.1
replies:
  3
from:
date:
  Nov-3 9:09 pm

I tried being `friends` the last 2 yrs. We always ended up friends with benefits [mostly his] as I ended  up emotionally sucked in again, and he not, or so he let on. I loved and felt  like part of his family too - I think that was almost harder  than letting  go of him, but blood is thicker than water,and they eventually closed ranks when we finally ended it. Its better to go cold turkey and let time and distance give you perspective, if you keep constant contact, you cant move on, and its painful and confusing for everyone. I still care and send him good thoughts and maybe someday down the road, we can be friends. I managed to do that with a former boyfriend, and now he`s like a brother. Be strong, and be kind to yourself!  Good luck..
last visit to this board
Nov-24


messages posted
this board
51

add to friends
ignore posts
discussion title:
 

After 5 years, can you be friends?

emoticon:
 emoticon
message #:
  27555.3 in response to 27555.1
replies:
  3
from:
date:
  Nov-24 1:18 pm

Can lovers ever really be friends...not really.

You WILL get over your first love..we all do, but it takes time and a few things.

You have to understand that if you are wanting to get over your ex, you need to break ALL contact with him, the family, and the sister. Yes...everyone. You have to start fresh in order to start over again, which means, deleting phone numbers, blocking/deleting e-mail addresses, changing phone numbers, and removing everything that reminds you of him.

Here's an example... If you ate something that made you sick, and you can't throw it up because it's painful. You have 2 options, force yourself to throw it up, or sit there in pain till eventually it goes away.

You can choose to sit and completely rationalize the situation several times over while times wastes away, or you can choose to make a decision to have ZERO contact and start to feel better about everything. Remember he never treated you right then, so he's not going to treat you right now, or ever.

Keeping in contact will make it more painful for you as time goes along and it will not get better. Keep yourself busy and move on.

Change the number of messages
displayed on this page in
Indicate your interest in the discussion
   
Get updates to this discussion
delivered by email